DIRECT IP PRINTING VS. CLIENT/SERVER PRINTING

The following tables list some of the common pros and cons for direct IP printing compared to client/server printing. You might identify other pros and cons specific to your environment.

Pros and cons of direct IP printing

+/-

Features

Implications

 

 

 

+

Lower equipment costs

Savings on equipment costs such as servers and print

 

 

servers

 

 

 

+

Easier setup

Setting up a direct IP print environment is easier than

 

 

setting up a server-based print environment

 

 

Offices that change locations frequently require less

 

 

assistance from IT

 

 

 

+

More user control over print jobs

Users maintain control of their print jobs throughout

 

 

the process, relieving IT of the responsibility of

 

 

managing print jobs at the servers

 

 

 

+

Distributed print environment

Limited impact to an enterprise as a whole when a

 

 

single printer fails

 

 

 

-

Increased training costs

Users are responsible for troubleshooting their print

 

 

jobs

 

 

 

+

Potential for increased worker

Users don’t have to search for drivers or resend print

 

productivity

jobs because they inadvertently tried to print to a

 

 

printer that wasn’t available

 

 

When Status Notification Prompts are enabled, users

 

 

are aware of real-time print job status

 

 

 

-

Limited number of users who can

25 concurrent users per printer are recommended

 

print in a given environment

depending on usage

 

 

 

+/-

Windows Point and Print

Driver update services are unnecessary since users

 

unavailable, and not necessary, to

download new versions of HP UPD when they

 

install printers and drivers

become available

 

 

 

-

Limited control over group printing

IT might not be able to prioritize print jobs

 

priority

 

 

 

 

-

No support for printer pooling or

May add complexity and management requirements

 

print clustering

 

 

 

 

-

Increased configuration complexity

A hostname change on a printer requires updating

 

 

all client computers

 

 

 

-

Policy concerns

Cannot restrict printing to specific IP address (such as

 

 

a server queue that only allows printing from select

 

 

users)

+/- Different IT tools are required to manage the printing environment

MPA and HP Active Directory templates are available for managing printer access lists and access to printer features

5