Reliant FORM 10-K manual Fixed or determinable fees-An increase of $133 million

Models: FORM 10-K

1 323
Download 323 pages 18.03 Kb
Page 230
Image 230

were recognized upon delivery of interim product solutions pending the availability of the later generation optical product that the customer had ordered. In this circumstance, revenues for the order should have been deferred until the undelivered element was delivered as we did not have evidence supporting the fair value of the undelivered element. Accordingly, we restated the recorded revenues, deferring recognition to subsequent periods, which had the effect of a net decrease to revenues of approximately $40 million in 2001 and an increase to revenues of approximately $190 million in 2002 and $25 million in 2003.

We also focused on accounting for software revenue recognition more generally, particularly in our Optical business. In Fall 2004, we sought the views of the SEC’s Office of the Chief Accountant, or OCA, on one issue with respect to our historical and continuing accounting treatment under U.S. GAAP of revenues recognized on sales of certain optical products containing embedded software. We advised the OCA that we believed our historical accounting treatment of these optical products was appropriate, and we were fully supported in this conclusion by D&T. We, in consultation with D&T, nevertheless decided to obtain the views of the OCA on our analysis and conclusions due to the judgments involved in the applicable accounting analysis and the significant impact a different conclusion could have had on our reported revenues (namely, the deferred recognition of substantial revenues over a number of subsequent years). Following discussions with us, the OCA did not approve or disapprove our accounting in this area, and we concluded that we would not make any adjustments to our accounting treatment of the sales of these optical products as part of the Second Restatement.

We also considered revenue recognition policies related to post-contract support, or PCS, with respect to all business lines, and identified certain Enterprise products that presented issues. For these products, we recognized revenues at the time of delivery of the product but before completion of PCS or other future services agreed to in the contract. Because in some cases we did not have vendor specific objective evidence of fair value for those services (for example, where we made available free software upgrades on our website), U.S. GAAP requires the revenues to be recognized over the PCS period. Accordingly, we corrected this error and deferred the revenues to subsequent periods, resulting in a net decrease to revenues of approximately $140 million in 2001 and $155 million in 2002 and a net increase of approximately $170 million in 2003.

Fixed or determinable fees—An increase of $133 million in 2002.

As a result of our focus on accounting for software revenue recognition more generally as described above, we identified a specific contract for which revenue for sales had been recognized but the criteria for revenue recognition had not been met, including the criteria that contract fees be either fixed or determinable. Accordingly, we corrected this error and deferred the revenues to subsequent periods when customer payments became due and all criteria for revenue recognition were met.

Reseller transactions—An increase of $151 million in 2001.

As a result of employee input, we determined that a certain reseller lacked economic substance apart from Nortel Networks at the time of the relevant transaction. In such a case, we should have deferred revenues and recognized them only upon the reseller’s sale of the products to an end customer. Accordingly, we corrected this error and deferred the revenues to subsequent periods.

Reciprocal arrangements—A decrease of approximately $55 million in 2000 and $20 million in 2001.

In our review of a particular contract in connection with other issues described above, we determined that it also involved a reciprocal arrangement with the customer. Instead of recognizing the full amount of

130

Page 230
Image 230
Reliant FORM 10-K manual Fixed or determinable fees-An increase of $133 million